The title is relevant for the article content: 3
The abstract presents the context and the contributions: 5
The introduction details the context: 10
The article presents some of the related work: 10
The article presents original contributions: 15
The article includes implementation details: 10
The article includes test results: 10
The conclusions outline the contributions: 6
The conclusions include future work: 2
The article contains references: 10
The refered sources are recent: 3
The subject is relevant to the domain: 5
The presentation and structure is logical in the paper progression: 3
Grammar, spelling, syntax and punctuation: 4
Clarity in writing: 4
Final grade: 100